For a while, people enjoyed sharing interesting, and often cautionary, tales from Zoom hearings and trials. (Who can forget Zoom cat lawyer?!?) That doesn’t seem to be as much of a thing anymore, perhaps because we have all become more accustomed to and adept at virtual hearings. But a recent unpublished decision from the Appellate Division shows that there are still lessons to learn.
In Hernandez v. La Fortaleza, Inc., plaintiff sued defendant after she allegedly slipped on an “uneven and raised . . . walking surface” at defendant’s restaurant. The case was bifurcated and proceeded to a virtual trial on liability. Before trial, the judge instructed counsel on the logistics of the virtual trial, including where witnesses could be seated, who could be in the room with them, who could speak with them, and how exhibits would be presented to them. Plaintiff’s counsel indicated that plaintiff would be his first witness and that counsel would not talk to plaintiff about her testimony during her testimony, “even if they broke for lunch.”
During plaintiff’s testimony, plaintiff’s counsel shared his screen with plaintiff to show her a picture of defendant’s property. Counsel asked plaintiff to use the cursor on her computer to identify the location of the fall. Plaintiff had trouble doing so and it appeared to the trial court that someone else was in the room helping her. When asked, plaintiff confirmed that it was her husband. Because he was a co-plaintiff, the trial court allowed him to stay in the room but instructed him to stand where he would be visible on the screen. When plaintiff continued having trouble using the cursor to identify where she fell, the trial court recessed for lunch and instructed plaintiff’s counsel to “straighten out” the issues “with the exhibits and the utilization of the cursor.”
This is when things took a turn for the worse, at least for plaintiff and her counsel.
Continue reading “Practice tip: Don’t coach your witnesses . . . during a break at trial . . . on tape . . . after the trial court warns you not to. “